Facebook competitions – rules are made to be changed!

16 Comments

Did you catch the news about Facebook’s about-turn on running competitions? Many businesses are using competitions run on their Facebook Page as a means of growing their audience, increasing interaction with fans, learning more about their fans’ likes and dislikes, showing a more fun or quirky side than normal and therefore being memorable, and growing their email database.

Until very recently, it was against the T&Cs that we all signed up to when we created a Page to run a competition directly on the wall of our business or fan Page.  The only option we had was to use a 3rd party app, which sat alongside our Page, as a way of collecting entries and running promotions. The risk in not playing by the rules was having your Page pulled down. However, that was rarely policed by Facebook, so there was a big divide between businesses playing by the rules and those that weren’t.

Well Facebook has put an end to that inequality by now pronouncing that you can run a contest directly on your Page wall and allow people to comment or ‘like’ as a means of entry or voting. Two things haven’t changed though – you still can’t use tagging as a way of taking part in a competition and you can’t run a competition on a personal timeline.

Thumbs up for Facebook

But hang on, before you go cancelling your subscriptions to apps, let me just tell you why I think using apps to run competitions will still be a very smart move:

  • Everyone and their dog will now be running contests off their Page wall, and many will be ill-conceived and scrappy. Who wants their contest to look like that? An app allows you to use a series of nicely-branded graphics which will give off the right image about your business. Doing the same as everyone else is rarely a good move in business.
  • Apps give you a lot more scope than just running a simple sweepstakes or photo popularity contest. Some (like Woobox) give you the option to include ‘virality’ options alongside entry – ie. if contestants tweet or post about your competition they get increased chances of winning. Others allow for polls and for entry and voting by friends. All of these could be achieved directly on a wall-based contest, but the result will probably be very difficult to monitor.
  • And that brings us to a really important point – all of the big name apps (Offerpop, Woobox, ShortStack, Tabsite and the rest) will pick your winner for you at random if necessary and will monitor voting and other actions automatically. Trying to do this yourself is a. difficult and b. risky. You run the gauntlet of not being seen to be fair by all the contestants who can openly see what is happening in the contest on your wall and will freely offer their opinion as to whether your choice of winner was correct. There are numerous publicized cases now of this happening and the result isn’t pretty and does very bad things for a business reputation.
  • Another huge advantage that using an app will give you is that it allows you to ask for an email address as a condition of entry. Why do you want an email address? Because the bottom line is the more ways you can find to communicate with customers and prospects, the more you can help them and ultimately, the more sales you will make. You already know that only 20% or so of your Facebook fans will see any information your post on your Page wall at any one time, so you need another way of contacting them too. Email gives you that and is well-recognised as a powerful marketing tool that goes hand-in-hand with social.
  • You still have to provide T&Cs of any contest to entrants plus make it clear that Facebook is in no way associated with or endorsing your competition. This again is potentially messy to do unless you link to a page on a website. Apps allow you to ensure entrants have clicked to say they have read the terms and agreed them before they enter.

So in my view, using an app to run a contest will generally win hands down in that it gives you an elegant, well-structured, professional-looking means of running a competition that will stand out from the potentially messy crowd. The email data you can collect will allow you to contact your newly-extended audience by email as well as via Facebook (who knows what rule change will come next?), giving you ownership of that data.

The only time when a wall-based competition might be the right choice would be when there is a need to increase engagement with new and existing fans on the Page itself.

As has always been the case, it is crucial to decide actually what you want to achieve from running a competition before you decide how to put it into action. Only then can you measure whether it has been a success or not and therefore learn how to do it even better next time.

If you’d like some help in setting up or running a contest for your business on Facebook then please contact me at juliaatbramblebuzzdotcodotuk, or via Facebook or Twitter and fire those questions over – I’m always glad to share what I’ve learned!.

Will you be trying a contest under the new rules? Let us know in the comments below.

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Reply

    nice post

    valuable information

    Thank you

      • Julia
      • January 29, 2014
      Reply

      Many thanks for your comment – I’m so glad you found it useful! Are you running Facebook competitions?

  2. Reply

    Julia, this is a very useful post, it’s great that you have shared it in the Linkedin group! We have created an infographics about the topic, http://blog.antavo.com/en/facebook-promotion-guidelines-update-on-facebook-competition-contest-apps/ feel free to republish it if you think it’s valuable.

      • Julia
      • August 28, 2013
      Reply

      Thanks for your kind words Zsuzsi. An infographic is a great idea – thanks for sharing!

  3. Reply

    Thanks for this post – really informative. Appreciate it.

      • Julia
      • August 28, 2013
      Reply

      Thanks so much for your feedback Carole – I’m delighted you found it helpful.

  4. Reply

    Thanks Julia!

      • Julia
      • August 28, 2013
      Reply

      Thanks for commenting Zoe!

  5. Reply

    Hey Julia! Good stuff here!

    The initial roll-out hypes up the new, free, in the news feed promo option. However, as you note well there are some drawbacks and limitations. Selecting a winner from random, outlining the terms and conditions, capturing entrant data for integrated marketing, etc, are all not covered in the quick, free, basic news feed option. That’s where a more robust tab app comes in and adds value for the professional marketer.

    Thanks for stopping by on my blog post on TabSite as well!

      • Julia
      • August 28, 2013
      Reply

      Hey Mike! Thanks for your comments and for highlighting why people should still seriously consider using apps like Tabsite for running promotions. Loved your detailed blog on the subject too!

  6. Reply

    Hi Julia – great post! I completely agree with your point of view on using Apps!

      • Julia
      • August 28, 2013
      Reply

      Thanks Juan. It will be interesting to see if we get deluged by a flood of page-hosted competitions now!

  7. Reply

    Julia,
    Thanks for writing such an informative article. It has given me a clear prospective on the new changes made by Facebook and the role of Apps for running a successful contest

      • Julia
      • August 28, 2013
      Reply

      Hi Harmeet,
      Thanks for your kind words. I’m glad it was useful. It will be interesting to see how the app developers respond!

      • Reply

        I know how we are going to respond. We are going to embrace it like we do every other change Facebook makes because there are good and bad to them all. This actually opens up opportunities for us to do things we could not do before…in the way of app posting on the timeline and announcing winners.

        We could get upset and think that contest apps etc are going to die with this change, but that is just not true. We just have to find ways to improve what is already here. At least this tells us that it is a legitimate way to get engagement etc if Facebook is looking for ways to allow it to happen…

        Thanks for the post.

          • Julia
          • August 28, 2013
          Reply

          Hi David,
          Thanks for your comments – can’t wait to see what new goodies you developers bring us. Working with Facebook certainly keeps everyone on their toes, but as you say the changes bring new opportunities and that’s what business is all about. Thanks so much for responding 🙂

More from our blog

See all posts

Grab your free copy of my essential guide and discover the secrets to creating a social buzz that builds your business.